Citing research by peter schwartz of the stanford research institute, alphastyle leadership in our western society is considered more masculine. More and more women are no longer taking the back seat. This article argues that it is necessary to critically discuss the whole idea of gender labelling leadership as masculine or feminine and suggests that we should be very careful and potentially aware of the unfortunate consequences when we. Just like service leadership, indigenous leadership, team, collaborative or missionoriented leadership, feminine leadership focuses on a wellrounded, healthier approach to business and community. Nevertheless, overall male workers do not have higher preference to work under masculine leadership style while females have higher preference for both masculine and feminine leadership styles. Pdf this paper focuses on the impact and effectiveness of feminine and masculine styles of leadership on contrasting genders in four. John gerzema, last year published the athena doctrine, which says that the masculine form of leadership is inadequate for todays challenges. Female leaders in the 21st century in a masculine world.
The masculine and feminine sides of leadership and. Feminine leadership is another one of the 21st century leadership models emerging out of the old, hierarchical, topdown, control leadership model. These new ideas on leadership are often seen by students of gender as indicating a feminine orientation. Instead, both men and women believe successful leaders need stereotypically masculine traits such as assertiveness and competence.
In two studies, both women and men saw communality as relatively unimportant for successful leadership, write psychologists andrea vial of yale university and jaime napier of new york universityabu dhabi. Pdf the effectiveness of feminine and masculine leadership styles. The impact of feminine identity and soft influence tactics. Participants approved of qualities like patience, sensitivity, and trustworthiness, but when forced to narrow their choices, these lost out to traits such as confidence, competitiveness. When we consider the nine characteristics research says are critical for effective leadership, roughly half are traditionally masculine and the others traditionally feminine. Women in leadership positions and the qualities they possess abstract often times women in leadership positions feel it necessary to adopt masculine traits and qualities to be perceived as effective. Reaching into ancient spiritual and mythical teachings, shakti leadership revives the feminine archetype in leadership. Embracing feminine and masculine power in business kindle edition by bhat, nilima, sisodia, raj. Leaders men and women need both masculine and feminine. The purpose of this study is to uncover the strength and power of feminine women in leadership positions. Often female leaders simply try to copy the male leadership style they are familiar with. These gender differences are also reflected in descriptive stereotypes about female and male leadership styles in that respondents believe that. Pdf feminine paths to leadership in italy perceptions.
So long as we continue to associate leadership with masculine features, we can expect female leaders to be evaluated more negatively even when their performance is higher than. Men and women think leaders should have masculine traits. Feminine paths to leadership in italy perceptions of female italian leaders in a masculine society. The style is a growing trend within businesses and is characterized by a form of transformational leadership style. The effectiveness of feminine and masculine leadership styles in. Klofstad2 1department of biology, duke university, durham, north carolina, united states of america, 2department of political science, university of miami, coral gables, florida. Take this 5minute quiz to discover your core energy. The solution she states is to balance the dominant alpha, or masculine leadership style, with the beta, a more feminine leadership style. Gender role selfconcept, categorical gender, and leadership style 6 likely to display feminine and masculine behaviors. A balance of both masculine and feminine strengths. Leaders femininity and masculinity kingston university research.
The results demonstrate that participants ratings of purported leaders masculinity and femininity indeed correlate very closely with their ratings of initiation of. India, canada, pakistan, and united kingdoms it sector. The purpose of this study is to examine and discuss whether women executives in the hospitality industry in hong kong adopt a feminine, masculine or genderneutral approach to leadership. Although the landscape of leadership is beginning to change in terms of gender equality, men still outnumber women in leadership roles. Lately, in fact, people have been talking about the need for these socalled feminine leadership traits. Individuals who reported that they exhibited these behaviors without the accompanying more supportive feminine behaviors were viewed as leaders in a higher percentage. We have read this dissertation and recommend that it be approved. Shakti leadership embracing feminine and masculine power.
Canada and the uk have higher preference for masculine leadership style. Canada and the uk have higher preference for masculine. How star wars made me rethink masculine and feminine. Embracing feminine and masculine power in business. Masculine traits are still linked to leadership pacific. Regardless of gender, we all contain both masculine and feminine energy and your leading energy reflects your inner nature and values. I look forward to your experiments with archetypically feminine and masculine leadership behaviors. According to moore, masculine psychology is made up of four major archetypes. Historically the picture of a successful leader has been decidedly male. Gender, race, class, and other elements of social difference are acknowledged to play an important role in the development of leadership styles. Why feminine leadership includes healing your sexuality. Feminine leadership the school of visibility women and. Learning to selfmonitor your masculine and feminine leadership style characteristics, and evaluate the situations theyre best suited for could mean a faster climb up the corporate ladder. Forbes coaches council is an invitationonly community for.
The masculine and feminine sides of leadership and culture. As long as we associate leadership with masculinity, women. In line with this consideration is has been suggested that undifferentiated womens and mens behavioral flexibility is limited bem, 1974. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. This paper focuses on the impact and effectiveness of feminine and masculine styles of leadership on contrasting genders in four different economies namely. How teams can leverage both masculine and feminine leadership. Part of the educational leadership commons, elementary. The feminine style of management is a management style generally characterized by more feminine quality soft skills and behaviors such as empathy, effective communication, and a generally more democratic or teamstyled work environment. But sometimes, in doing so, they lose their femininity and.
The concepts of what makes an effective leader are changing. Serious business by mcad library is licensed under cc by 2. Great leaders balance masculine traits with feminine wisdom. This does not mean that you must give up your mancard, but it. Preference for leaders with masculine voices holds in the. Perceived feminine vs masculine leadership qualities in. The effectiveness of feminine and masculine leadership. Are the most popular leadership traits masculine or feminine. Generally speaking, leadership trainings tend to promote a more aggressive, get it done at all. Despite expectations that stereotypically feminine leadership traits like communality will. By combining probability and nonprobability sampling techniques, the data has been gathered from 248 respondents via semistructured 5points scale survey questionnaire.
Moreover, female linemanagers in the uk have shown higher masculine style of leadership in contrast to other economies. Pauls masculine and feminine leadership marg mowczko. One thats emotionally intelligent, values people and planet, and integrates feminine and masculine principles and values. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading shakti leadership. Preference for leaders with masculine voices holds in the case of feminine leadership roles rindy c. Published in frontiers in psychology as part of a research collection on gender roles in the future, the study is the first to examine potential tradeoffs in masculine versus feminine leadership traits. Masculine and feminine leadership approaches in public education, having been approved in respect to style and intellectual content, is referred to you for judgment. Your feminine and masculine traits greatness leadership. The study finds both men and women view stereotypically masculine traits like competence and.
More and more leadership models recognize the value of feminine strengths inclusiveness, empathy, listening, humility, etc. A problem only arises when the development of the feminine comes at the expense of the masculine. But true feminine leadership includes those women who choose to no longer play in the old boys club trying to act like men. Consciously integrate and leverage both your masculine and feminine traits in your leadership jack zenger and joseph folkman are certainly not surprised, who surveyed the 360 feedbacksurveys of 7,280 leaders, and found out that women were rated higher in 12 of 16 competencies for leadership at high level, including. Learn how leadership teams who know how to communicate effectively across gender can enact each of. Masculine and feminine leadership approaches in public education, authorjoseph p eberhard, year2017 joseph p eberhard published 2017 sociology doi. Oneill, phd and charles oreilly, stanford graduate school of business 2011 finding.
Direct, dominant, and careeroriented were each identified as masculine traits. True feminine leadership has a whole new set of rules. Kitegirl annabelle drumm looks at the difference between masculine and feminine leadership and how the world is moving more towards. This metaanalysis addresses this debate by quantitatively summarizing gender differences in perceptions of leadership effectiveness across 99 independent samples from 95 studies. The impact of feminine identity and soft influence tactics on leadership style asha kaul jithesh kumar k. Yet, while insisting that leadership is a masculine trait, complementarians do not seem to have a problem with women who lead or teach women or children. If your leadership style is more feminine and you are in a masculine culture, you have role incongruity, and you may not be that effective because people will perceive you as not fitting. Stereotypical masculine behaviors are still considered important for leadership. Pakistan and india there is significant use of feminine leadership while developed economies namely. If the question is one of equality, then there is certainly still a lot to be done to unpack gender stereotypes in relation to modern society, organizations and leadership, as well as to ascertain whether gender is indeed of such importance to leadership. Both masculine and feminine approaches have strengths and limitations. In order for a man to achieve mature masculine strength and energy, he must be in touch with all four. Whether we are male, female or transgender, we have been trained to value leadership qualities that are traditionally thought of as masculine. When an organization is dominated by either masculine or feminine approaches, there is.
773 531 967 1524 1510 659 1431 1054 1226 1339 1367 743 870 240 159 1293 238 557 355 267 1082 65 226 1211 596 483 321 1466 1336 1262 1163 228 1123 672 714 254 1481 517 1197 691 90 647 1093